TLDR
The best place to buy MTG proxies depends on what you need. ProxyMTG.com is the best pick for deck-building tools and bulk pricing. PrintMTG.com is best for high-quality print on demand proxies with strong cardstock and service. ProxyKing.biz is best for single staples, dual lands, and realistic proxy cards.
For print-at-home testing, use MTGprint. For cubes and large custom batches, consider ProxyPrintery or MakePlayingCards with MPCFill. Avoid PrintingProxies for bulk orders if price matters, since its published high-volume pricing is much higher than ProxyMTG and PrintMTG. Avoid Proxxied if you are trying to buy finished cards, because it is a browser-based print-at-home tool, not a finished-card seller.
What This Guide Covers
Buying MTG proxies can mean a few different things. Some players want a full Commander deck printed and shipped. Some want a few expensive staples for casual play. Some want a print-at-home PDF. Some want custom cards, double-sided cards, foil upgrades, or an entire cube.
This guide is for players who want to know where to buy MTG proxies, what each site is best at, how pricing works, and how to place an order without creating a pile of unusable cards.
The selection criteria are simple: print quality, cardstock fidelity, price per card, bulk-order value, ordering tools, decklist import support, turnaround, reputation, realistic appearance, and whether the site is better for casual play, playtesting, custom cards, or full-deck production.
The short version: start with ProxyMTG.com, PrintMTG.com, or ProxyKing.biz if you want finished cards. Use MTGprint if you want print-at-home control. Use MPC if you are comfortable with a more involved workflow and want low per-card pricing on custom deck production.
Why Choose MTG Proxies
Players use MTG proxies for three main reasons: casual play, playtesting, and protecting expensive Magic cards.
Casual play is the big one. Commander players often want to try a mana base, a few Reserved List cards, a cEDH shell, or a new deck idea without spending hundreds or thousands of dollars first. A proxy lets the group focus on the game instead of everyone’s collection value.
Playtesting is another good use. If you are tuning a cube, testing a new Commander list, or trying cards before buying real copies, proxies save time and money. You can test ten versions of a card package before deciding which real cards are worth buying.
Protection matters too. If you own expensive MTG cards, you may not want to shuffle them every week. ProxyKing describes proxies as stand-ins that let players avoid damaging high-value cards, especially expensive staples, dual lands, fetch lands, and other cards that can be costly to replace.
Proxies are also useful for custom cards. Some players print custom commanders, cube cards, joke cards, tokens, alternate art versions, or entire deck projects. This is where services like PrintMTG, ProxyMTG, ProxyPrintery, MTGprint, and MPC start to feel very different from each other.
How We Chose The Best MTG Proxies
The first filter is print quality. A good proxy should be readable, centered well enough for sleeved play, and printed on cardstock that does not feel like paper in a sleeve. For higher-end orders, S33 German black-core stock is a common premium choice because it has a black-core center layer that blocks light and gives cards a more finished feel.
The second filter is price. A few single cards can cost more per card and still make sense. A full Commander deck, cube update, or 500-card bulk order needs better pricing. ProxyMTG and PrintMTG both publish bulk pricing that drops as low as $0.30 per card at 1,000+ cards.
The third filter is ordering friction. Decklist import matters. Searching card by card is fine for five cards. It is not fine for a full cube unless you enjoy turning admin work into a second hobby.
The fourth filter is reputation and use case. Some sellers are best for realistic singles. Some are better for high-volume deck building. Some are better for home printing. And some are fine products but not the best value for the job.
Best 6 Sites To Buy MTG Proxies For Deck Building
1. ProxyMTG
ProxyMTG.com is the strongest first stop for players who want to print MTG proxies from a decklist, build large orders, and keep pricing clear. It is built around Commander, cube, casual play, and deck testing, with tools for browsing sets, searching cards, uploading lists, choosing versions, and checking out.
Its main strength is bulk pricing. ProxyMTG lists a single card at $3, then $2 per card for 2–9 cards. Pricing drops as the order grows: $1.50 at 10–29 cards, $1.25 at 30–49, $1 at 50–74, $0.80 at 75–99, $0.55 at 100–199, $0.45 at 200–499, $0.35 at 500–999, and $0.30 at 1,000+ cards.
That makes it especially good for full Commander decks, cube updates, and larger playtest batches.
Ordering And Import Decks
The cleanest ProxyMTG workflow is to upload a decklist or build a list inside the order tool. The site says users can browse the card library, choose versions, adjust quantities, and watch pricing update as the order grows.
A typical order looks like this:
- Export your decklist from Moxfield, Archidekt, MTGGoldfish, or your deck app.
- Paste or upload the list when supported.
- Review card names, quantities, and set versions.
- Choose any custom backs or proxy markings.
- Review pricing.
- Check shipping and delivery details.
- Place the order.
ProxyMTG states that it prints on premium S33 German black-core cardstock with a UV coating, which is a good sign if you want cards that feel more like finished game pieces than paper inserts.
Double-Sided MTG Proxies And Foil Options
For double-sided cards, check the current order builder and ask support if the option is not obvious. ProxyMTG’s public customization guidelines mention custom backs and printed “holo stamp” style graphics when offered, but also clarifies that those are printed graphics, not physical foil stamps or authentication features.
That distinction matters. If you need true foil upgrades or double-sided MTG proxies, confirm the option before placing a large order. Do not assume every proxy printer handles MDFCs, transform cards, custom backs, and foil effects the same way.
Best for: full Commander decks, cube updates, large-volume deck building, and players who want strong pricing without building an MPC order themselves.
Contact: ProxyMTG lists support@proxymtg.com as its customer service email and asks customers to include an order number for the quickest response.

2. PrintMTG
PrintMTG.com is one of the best options if quality, service, and a clean ordering process matter most. It focuses on finished MTG proxy cards for kitchen-table games, playtesting, Cube, and Commander. The site says it prints on premium black-core playing-card stock with standard TCG sizing and a smooth finish.
PrintMTG’s order flow is simple: upload or paste your decklist, choose card versions, review the order, and let the site handle printing and shipping. It also supports custom card design through its MTG Card Maker for custom art, alternate frames, gifts, and original card concepts.
The recommended stock is S33 German Black Core if you want a premium feel. PrintMTG specifically lists S33 German Black Core playing-card stock, standard TCG sizing, and most orders shipping in about two business days.
Its bulk pricing is also strong. PrintMTG lists $2 per card for 2–9 cards and drops to $0.45 at 200–499, $0.35 at 500–999, and $0.30 at 1,000+ cards.
PrintMTG is best for players who want a polished finished product and do not want the extra setup work of MPCFill. It is also a good fit for custom cards where readability and cardstock quality matter.
Best for: high-quality finished proxies, full deck orders, custom cards, and players who want strong service without too much setup.
Contact: PrintMTG lists support@printmtg.com and phone support at 720-803-1314, with support hours from 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. Monday through Friday.
3. ProxyKing
ProxyKing.biz is best for single staples, dual lands, fetch lands, Power 9-style sets, and realistic proxy cards. It is less of a decklist-printing workflow and more of a storefront for individual staple cards and curated sets.
That is useful if you only need a handful of cards. Maybe you want a dual land set for a cube. Maybe you want a few Commander staples. Maybe you are tired of moving the same expensive cards from one deck to another.
ProxyKing sells individual MTG proxy cards and grouped proxy sets. Its sets page lists products like Dual Land Set, Shock Land Set, Fetch Land Set, Triome Set, Medallion Set, Sword Equipment Set, and Power 9 Set. Prices vary by set and finish, with many land sets shown around $25 and some foil sets around $30 at the time checked.
ProxyKing also leans into realistic proxy cards. It says its cards use high-quality printing, premium cardstock, and the same dimensions as typical Magic cards. It also notes that color can vary between print runs and recommends sleeving proxy cards during play.
Best for: single staples, dual lands, mana bases, Reserved List cards, realistic proxies, and players who do not need an entire deck printed from a list.
Contact: ProxyKing lists ProxyMtG@Protonmail.com as its main customer service email and 214-617-8162 as its phone number.
4. MTGprint
MTGprint is not a finished-card seller. It is the best option for print-at-home users who want quick test proxies without ordering cards online.
MTGprint is a free CardTrader tool that lets you paste a Magic Arena-format decklist, generate a PDF, print it, cut the cards, and sleeve them.
This is the cheapest and fastest option if you already have a printer, paper, sleeves, and bulk cards to put behind the printouts. It is also the easiest option for quick testing. You can update a decklist, print a few pages, and start testing the same day.
The tradeoff is quality. Home-printed proxies are usually fine for kitchen-table testing, but they will not feel like professionally printed cards unless you put in a lot of extra work. They may also look less clean, especially if your printer struggles with small text, dark frames, or color consistency.
Best for: print-at-home testing, fast deck experiments, low-cost proxy sheets, and players who care more about speed than finished-card feel.
Contact: MTGprint’s FAQ lists an email contact for feedback.
5. ProxyPrintery
ProxyPrintery is a strong option for players who want flexible stock options, custom cards, bulk ordering, and European shipping. It offers standard paper, black core, and holo foil options, and claims prices as low as €0.29 per card.
Its best feature is flexibility. ProxyPrintery supports decklist links, paper selection, tokens, sideboards, and larger order workflows. Its decklist-link product page instructs users to enter a decklist link, add more links if needed, set the total number of cards, choose whether to print tokens and sideboards, select a paper option, then add the order to cart.
ProxyPrintery also supports custom designs through Google Drive links or XML files from MPCFill, and it states that custom card backs do not require an extra fee. It also offers double-sided cards, but says it adds a small “ProxyPrintery” mark to double-sided cards on black core stock to reduce counterfeiting risk.
Fulfillment is listed as usually taking 2–5 business days depending on order size and workload, with printing and shipping on Mondays and Thursdays.
Best for: cubes, bulk orders, flexible stock choices, custom designs, double-sided cards, and EU-based or international players.
Contact: ProxyPrintery points customers to its support page, email, and Discord support.
6. MakePlayingCards / MPC
MakePlayingCards, usually called MPC by proxy players, is the best option for repeat custom deck production if you are comfortable with a more technical workflow.
MPC is not an MTG proxy site in the same way ProxyMTG or PrintMTG are. It is a custom game card manufacturer. It lets you order custom game cards in 63 x 88 mm size, upload your own fronts and backs, and choose card stocks, boxes, wrapping, and other options. Its custom game card page says decks can range from 18 to 612 cards and each card can be customized.
The usual proxy workflow is MPCFill plus MPC. MPCFill describes itself as a free, open-source tool for printing professional-quality playtest cards with MakePlayingCards. It lets users choose community renders, build a project, and use a desktop tool to place an order with MPC.
This is often one of the lowest per-card approaches for large custom decks, but it takes more work. You need to understand image choices, bleed, card backs, order slots, stock selection, and the MPC ordering process.
For stock, S33 Superior Smooth is a common premium choice. MPC says S33 has a black-core center layer, premium smooth finish, and no minimum order quantity requirement.
Best for: repeat custom deck production, cubes, custom backs, alternate art projects, and players who want control over every file.
Contact: MPC uses a contact form and sales/technical team contact links for custom game card questions.
Where To Buy Proxies: Quick Buy Sheet
Use ProxyMTG if you want the best combination of deck-building tools and bulk pricing. It is the cleanest first choice for large-volume deck building.
Use PrintMTG if you care most about finished-card quality, S33 cardstock, quick production, and customer service.
Use ProxyKing.biz if you want realistic proxy cards, single staples, dual lands, fetch lands, Power 9-style sets, and easy add-to-cart ordering.
Use MTGprint if you want print-at-home proxy sheets for testing tonight.
Use ProxyPrintery if you want flexible stock options, double-sided cards, holo foil, cubes, and bulk custom orders.
Use MPC if you want custom full-deck production at a low per-card cost and do not mind a more hands-on setup.
Avoid PrintingProxies.com for bulk orders if price is your main concern. Its published pricing drops to $0.75 per card at 200+ cards, while ProxyMTG and PrintMTG publish $0.45 per card at 200–499 cards and $0.30 at 1,000+ cards.
Avoid Proxxied if you are trying to buy finished cards. Proxxied is a free browser-based deck and proxy-sheet generator for printing at home, not a shipped-card print shop.
Quick Comparison Of The Best MTG Proxies
| Site | Best For | Pricing Notes | Main Tradeoff |
|---|---|---|---|
| ProxyMTG.com | Large-volume deck building | $3 single, down to $0.30 at 1,000+ | Confirm specialty options before large orders |
| PrintMTG.com | High-quality finished proxies | Down to $0.30 at 1,000+ | More expensive than DIY printing |
| ProxyKing.biz | Single staples and realistic proxies | Singles often around $4, sets vary | Not the best full decklist workflow |
| MTGprint | Print-at-home users | Free tool, you pay paper/ink | Lower finished quality |
| ProxyPrintery | Stock flexibility and cubes | Claims as low as €0.29/card | Ships from Germany |
| MPC / MPCFill | Custom full-deck production | Often low per-card at volume | Most setup work |

How To Place An MTG Proxy Order
Prepare Your Decklist And Files
Start by exporting your decklist in a common format. Most proxy sites work better with plain card names and quantities. If your deck contains special printings, alternate art versions, double-faced cards, or Universes Beyond versions, check every card carefully before ordering.
For custom cards, collect high-resolution art. Low-resolution images will usually print poorly. Keep important text and art away from the edge, especially if the service shows a bleed preview.
Before checkout, verify:
- Card names.
- Quantities.
- Set versions.
- Card backs.
- Double-sided card handling.
- Foil choices.
- Custom art rights.
- Shipping address.
- Delivery timing.
This is boring. It also prevents expensive mistakes.
Import Decks And Upload Files
If the site supports decklist import, use it. Paste the decklist or a decklist link, then review the imported cards manually. Decklist tools can misread split cards, MDFCs, alternate names, or special versions.
If you are uploading your own card artwork, use the highest-resolution files available. JPG and PNG files can work, but make sure they are sharp at print size. For MPC-style workflows, check that the image includes enough bleed and does not cut off borders, text, or art.
For a large project, test one print sample or a small order first. A single test order can tell you a lot about cardstock, color, centering, finish, and shuffle feel.
https://company.wizards.com/en
Choose Stock, Foil, And Double-Sided Options
Stock choice matters more than most first-time buyers expect. S33 German black-core stock is a premium option used by several proxy workflows because it has a black core, smooth finish, and better light blocking.
Compare S33 against other stocks when the seller offers multiple options. Some players prefer the closest in-sleeve feel. Others care more about price. For casual Commander, consistency across the whole deck often matters more than matching real cards exactly.
Decide on foil and double-sided cards before checkout. Foil looks great when done well, but it can add cost and glare. Double-sided cards can be useful for MDFCs and transform cards, but you should make sure the service adds responsible proxy markings and shows a clear preview.
Always check centering and bleed previews. If the card frame is too close to the edge, the final card may look off-center even if the printer does a decent job.
How To Choose The Right MTG Proxy Service
Choose Based On Price Per Card
If you need 5 cards, use a single-card vendor like ProxyKing, ProxyMTG, or PrintMTG. The per-card price will be higher, but the order is simple.
If you need a full Commander deck, cube update, or many decks, use a bulk discount service. ProxyMTG and PrintMTG are strong because their pricing drops heavily at larger quantities. ProxyPrintery and MPC also become attractive for large orders, especially if you are comfortable with more setup.
Choose Based On High-Quality MTG Output
If quality is the priority, choose vendors that disclose cardstock, finish, standard sizing, and proof or preview behavior. PrintMTG and ProxyMTG both mention premium black-core stock. ProxyPrintery lists standard, black core, and holo foil stock options. MPC gives you direct stock control if you know what you are doing.
Also look for real customer photo reviews. Marketing photos can be helpful, but customer images are better for checking color, centering, borders, and how cards look next to authentic cards.
Choose Based On Use Case: Casual Play Vs Tournament Testing
For casual play, readability and group agreement matter most. A clearly marked proxy in an opaque sleeve is usually less stressful than a card trying too hard to look authentic.
For serious playtesting, use higher-fidelity proxies. If you are testing sequencing, shuffling, card recognition, or deck feel, paper printouts may be fine early on. Once the list is closer to final, finished proxies on decent cardstock make the testing feel more realistic.
For sanctioned events, do not assume proxies are allowed. Wizards of the Coast’s proxy policy states that cards used in DCI-sanctioned events must be authentic Magic cards, except for judge-issued temporary proxies when a card becomes damaged during the event.
Which Option Is Best For You?
Choose ProxyMTG.com if you need deck tools, clear bulk pricing, and a straightforward print-on-demand workflow.
Choose PrintMTG.com if quality and customer service matter most, especially if you want S33 black-core stock and a polished finished product.
Choose ProxyKing.biz if you want realistic single staples, dual lands, fetch lands, Power 9-style sets, and other high-value cards without building a whole decklist order.
Choose MTGprint if you prefer print-at-home control and want to test cards quickly.
Choose ProxyPrintery if you want stock flexibility, holo foil, double-sided cards, cube support, and bulk savings.
Choose MPC if you want custom entire deck production, custom backs, repeated deck projects, and the lowest practical cost once you know the workflow.
Legal Notes And Etiquette For Magic: The Gathering Play
Do not pass proxies off as real MTG cards. That is the line that makes everyone nervous, and for good reason.
Use proxies for casual play, home games, Commander pods, cubes, and playtesting where everyone agrees ahead of time. Ask your playgroup before using proxies. Ask your store or event organizer before bringing proxies to a store event.
Also match the power level. A proxy deck can go from “I wanted to test a few cards” to “surprise, every deck is now cEDH” very quickly. That may be fine if the table wants it. It is not fine if everyone else brought precons.
Good proxy etiquette is simple:
- Tell people you are using proxies.
- Keep the cards readable.
- Use sleeves.
- Do not make them deceptive.
- Do not sell or trade them as authentic cards.
- Keep power level expectations clear.
- Do not use proxies in sanctioned events unless a judge specifically issues one under tournament policy.
Wizards has said playtest cards for personal, non-commercial use outside sanctioned events are not what it is trying to police, but it is very clear that sanctioned events require authentic cards and that counterfeits are a separate problem.

Vendor Links And Contact Info
| Vendor | Best Contact Method |
|---|---|
| ProxyMTG.com | support@proxymtg.com; contact page and order number recommended for support. |
| PrintMTG.com | support@printmtg.com; phone listed as 720-803-1314. |
| ProxyKing.biz | ProxyMtG@Protonmail.com; phone listed as 214-617-8162. |
| MTGprint | Feedback email listed in FAQ. |
| ProxyPrintery | Support page, Discord, and email support. |
| MakePlayingCards / MPC | Contact form and sales/technical team support through its custom card pages. |
Final Thoughts
The best MTG proxy site depends on the tradeoff you care about most. ProxyMTG is the best broad pick for deck tools and bulk pricing. PrintMTG is excellent for finished-card quality and service. ProxyKing is best for realistic single staples and proxy sets. MTGprint is best for fast DIY testing. ProxyPrintery is strong for flexible stock and cubes. MPC is best when you want custom full-deck production and do not mind doing more setup.
My practical advice: test one small order before printing an entire deck. Check the cardstock, color, text clarity, centering, finish, and shuffle feel. Once you find the service that matches your expectations, save the specs and reorder from the same setup.
FAQs
Where Is The Best Place To Buy MTG Proxies?
Proxy MTG is the best overall pick for deck-building tools and bulk pricing. Print MTG is best for finished-card quality, and Proxy King is best for single staples and realistic proxy cards.
Are MTG Proxies Legal?
MTG proxies are not legal in sanctioned Magic events unless a judge issues a temporary proxy for a damaged card during that event. They are commonly used in casual play and playtesting when the group agrees.
What Is The Cheapest Way To Print An Entire Commander Deck?
The cheapest finished-card route is usually MPC or a bulk discount service. ProxyMTG and PrintMTG both publish pricing that drops as low as $0.30 per card at 1,000+ cards. MTGprint is cheaper if you print at home, but the quality depends on your printer and materials.
Should I Buy Single Proxies Or Print A Full Deck?
Buy single proxies if you only need a few staples. Print a full deck if you are testing a complete Commander list, building a cube, or want consistent cardstock and finish across the whole deck.
What Stock Should I Choose For High-Quality MTG Proxies?
S33 German black-core stock is a strong premium option. It has a black-core center layer and a smooth finish, which helps cards feel more like finished game cards in sleeves.
Can I Use Proxies At My Local Game Store?
Ask first. Casual games may allow proxies if the group agrees, but sanctioned events require authentic cards unless a judge issues a temporary proxy under tournament rules.


